Practice · 11

Disputes, tribunals and negotiated resolution

A dispute starts with a good letter and a hard conversation with the other side. The practice does both, and hands the rare court matter to someone who lives there.

DOCET LEGAL runs commercial disputes outside the courtroom: negotiation, mediation, settlement deeds, tribunal and commission matters, and arbitration and expert determination. The letter and negotiation stage is usually a fixed fee. Mediation, tribunal, arbitration and expert determination work is quoted stage by stage, in writing, before it starts.

The work

Disputes are where the earlier decisions come home. The contract that was never reviewed, the partner who was never asked what happens on exit, the invoice terms that never mentioned interest. By the time the practice is involved, the question is not who is right. It is what outcome is worth having, and the cheapest route to it.

The practice negotiates, mediates and acts in the tribunals and commissions where many commercial and workplace disputes are resolved, with leave where a lawyer needs it: the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, the Fair Work Commission, the NSW Small Business Commissioner's mediation service, the anti-discrimination bodies, and the ombudsman schemes that cover telecommunications, energy, finance and other industries. It also acts in arbitrations and expert determinations in NSW where a contract sends the dispute there. It drafts the deed that ends the matter.

What it does not do is run contested court proceedings. That is a deliberate line, and it is drawn early rather than late. If a matter needs a court, the practice says so, prepares the file, and hands it to a litigator. No fee changes hands for the referral, in either direction.

This work includes

  • Contract and payment disputes
  • Shareholder and partnership disputes
  • Franchise disputes
  • Supplier and customer disputes
  • Without prejudice negotiation
  • Mediation, including the NSW Small Business Commissioner
  • Arbitration and expert determination
  • NCAT and other tribunals
  • Fair Work Commission
  • Anti-discrimination and human rights complaints
  • Ombudsman and industry complaint schemes
  • Settlement deeds and releases
  • Preparing a matter for a litigator

How it usually runs

  1. What the dispute is actually about

    Usually money, sometimes control, occasionally principle. Once the costs agreement is signed, the practice works out with you what outcome is worth having.

  2. The letter that sets the position

    A firm, specific letter from the practice. Many disputes are resolved in the exchange that follows.

  3. Mediation or a tribunal, before a court

    Mediation often resolves a commercial dispute at a fraction of the cost of litigation. Where a tribunal or commission has jurisdiction, the practice runs the matter there, with the tribunal's leave or permission where a lawyer needs it. Where the contract sends the dispute to arbitration or an expert in NSW, the practice runs it there. Where only a court will do, the file is handed to a litigator with the documents in order and the position set out.

  4. A deed that ends it

    A settlement that is not properly documented tends to come back. The practice drafts the deed of settlement and release to close the matter off as fully as the law allows.

Where the line is

  • Court litigation is the line. The practice does not run contested proceedings in any court. When a dispute needs one, it goes to a litigator, with the practice's work on the file going with it.
  • Tribunals, commissions and ombudsman schemes are not courts. Matters in the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal and the Fair Work Commission are within the practice, with the leave or permission a lawyer needs to appear in them, as are complaints to the Anti-Discrimination Board of NSW and the Australian Human Rights Commission, which conciliate rather than decide, and industry ombudsman schemes.
  • Arbitration and expert determination are not court proceedings either. Where a contract sends a dispute to arbitration or to an expert, and the arbitration or determination is in New South Wales under NSW law, the practice acts in it. If it can't act in a particular arbitration or determination, it says so at the start and refers the matter, with the file prepared. Court applications connected with an arbitration or an expert determination, such as an application to stay court proceedings brought despite an arbitration clause, an application to set aside an award or an application to enforce one, are court work and go to a litigator. Some of them have short time limits, so the referral is made as soon as the need arises.

Nobody pays anybody for a referral here, in either direction. How the practice hands work on →

Common questions

  • Why would a firm choose not to litigate?

    Because for most commercial disputes it is the wrong tool. Court is slow, public and expensive, and the outcome is rarely the one either side would have designed. A practice that does not litigate is built around resolving a matter before it reaches court. When a court is genuinely the answer, the practice says so early and hands over a well-prepared file.

  • What does the NSW Small Business Commissioner do?

    Provides low-cost mediation for disputes involving small businesses, including many contract and supplier disputes. For some kinds of dispute, mediation is a required step before a tribunal or court will hear the matter. The practice prepares for and attends these mediations regularly.

  • The other side has sent a letter. Should I reply myself?

    Read it, do not reply in anger, and send it over before you answer. What you write in the first reply gets quoted back for the life of the dispute. A short, considered response from the practice usually costs less than undoing a hasty one.

  • How much does a dispute cost?

    The letter and negotiation stage is usually a fixed fee. Mediation, tribunal, arbitration and expert determination work is quoted stage by stage in writing, with the estimate revised if the matter changes shape. You will be told, honestly, when the cost of continuing is approaching the value of what is in dispute, because that is the moment to settle.

Make an enquiry

Send a short note about what is happening. You will hear back within one business day with whether the practice can help and the fee basis. The fee is confirmed in writing before any work starts.

Send an enquiry All practice areas →